Photo opportunity courtesy of my friend
Tinlizard (check out his gallery pics for more pictures of this
awesome project!). Click
here to see more pictures and information!
This page is aimed at
helping you with choice and setup of dual 1bbl carburetors. This
page is a work in progress.
There are a few different common aftermarket dual 1bbl carb setups out
there, namely:
More suited to smaller engine setups (based on carburetor size).
Kadrons are a little larger than the others and can supply engines a
little larger than the others
Odd firing characteristics at idle and low speed/low throttle plate angle
Frequently use balance tubes to help with odd firing and synchronization
Frequently need work on the throttle body section to improve function
Sensitive to float settings
Sensitive to fuel pressure
Individual characteristics, settings, and issues
Weber 34ICT
Fixed (cast in) venturi. 29mm size
Asymmetric throttle action (both throttles turn the same way)
No choke assemblies
Throttle body is integrated to lower body section
Throttle shaft has plastic seals at the ends in the shaft bore of the
body, shaft rides on casting bore
Equipped with vacuum ports suitable for SVDA carburetor
Fuel pressure: 3-3.5 PSI
Typical jetting at sea level: 55-60 idle, 135 main, 160 air
Float attached to cover, easy to measure and adjust the float height
Float settings vary in the books - some refer to setting them to about
6-7mm and some refer to setting them to 7-8mm. The best results come
from 6mm from my experience. If you are going to drive off road and
bounce around you will have to drop them a millimeter or two. Setting the
floats is critical and MUST BE DONE RIGHT! Below is a diagram of how to
measure the float height. When you set the float height you want to position
the
carburetor so that the float barely rests on the spring ball on the needle portion
of the needle and seat. If the ball is compressed, the measurement is wrong.
Parts diagram (click on it for full
size with parts list)
Float settings diagram
Make sure that the needle valve seats correctly (all the way in)
Hold the cover vertically so the float does not compress the
spring ball (SF) in needle S
With the cover vertical, and the float tab (LC) lightly touching
the spring ball (SF), measure from the float (G) to the cover gasket
(GZ). The distance should be about 6mm.
To adjust, you have to bend the tab (LC) a little either way to
get the setting right. You can also slightly bend the spot
where the float canister attaches to the flat plate, to try to get
it closer without using the tab (LC).
Common problems
Throttle shaft bores wear badly on these causing the seals to flex
and leak - these need to be bushed, sometimes even new ones are sloppy.
Throttle shafts tend to have lots of end play, which causes
linkage slop and errata. These are correctable by rebushing the
carburetors and using special shims to correct end play. End play
matters, as far as linkage is concerned as well as potentially
causing throttle plate and bore wear, when the plates scrape the
sides of the throttle body. Many of these come to me with plate
wear, which isn't usually bad enough to need new plates. This is a
good thing because throttle plates aren't readily available for
them.
Accelerator pump squirters are difficult to remove. The o-ring
becomes hard or very dry, causing difficulty removing it. One thing that
really helps is to warm up the carburetor body in some very hot tap
water, or a little warmer. Heat a pot of water up to a temperature
of close to 150 degrees or so, that should be enough to get it going.
Grab the pump squirter with some needle nose pliers, twist it and pull it
up and push it down several times, being careful not to tear up the top
of the squirter where you are holding it with the pliers. The squirter
should loosen up and pull out.
Emulsion tube under the air jet can be difficult to remove. Make
a piece of stiff wire with a short bend in the end and fish it down
into the tube. Lock the bent end into one of the holes in the tube,
and pull up
Solex/Brosol 32-34PDSI (CB Performance kit)
Removable venturi - allows different sizes
Symmetric throttle action (there are a -2 and -3 model, one for each
side, and they rotate opposite directions
electric choke, fast idle linkage in the choke housing, gives fast
idle on choke action
Separate throttle body under the main carburetor body
Throttle shaft rides on bearing inserts in the throttle body
Equipped with vacuum ports suitable for SVDA carburetor
Fuel pressure: 3-3.5 PSI (this is true for MANY Solex carburetors with
similar inlet valves)
Typical jetting at sea level: 55 idle, 130 main, 140 air + 90 fixed
air on the newer ones. I think the older ones were 55/135/150/100
Float attached to cover on later units, some earlier units have a
hinge pin in the lower body section
Float settings - I don't have technical information on how these
are supposed to be set. These are not the same as the stock
32-34PDSIT carburetors found on 1972-1974 Type 4 engines in Bay
window Buses. The later version of these have the float attached to
the cover, which tends to be a matter of setting the float
height/angle. Out of the box, these do seem to be ok, though, I
believe that they have one 0.5mm washer under the needle and seat.
There are some older ones that have the float pivoting on a pin in
the lower body section, and I think those are supposed to have a
fuel level of about 12-14mm from the top of the lower body section
when the float is still installed.
Common problems:
In the few I have worked with and installed, I have seen a lot of
problems with these units, though once the kinks are worked out they do
seem to be good units. I think the biggest problem with them is the
assembly quality control.
Float pulled out of the needle keeper, which will cause the
carburetor to not fill, or to flood. I found the following on the last
set I installed.
Left carb choke shaft arm bent (the part that the choke tang attaches
to.
Left carb choke fast idle stop bent causing left carb to never fully
return throttle.
Right carb choke shaft tight, causing choke to stick in the partially
engaged position. Fixed with precision impact device.
Linkage center piece fouled the shroud in a big way, causing us to
have to clearance it beyond what is reasonable. The shroud was one of
those wonderful aftermarket 36HP shrouds, so that could have been part
of that problem.
One of the removable air jets was missing! CB Performance sent a
replacement.
Left side float was out of the keeper and had to be reinstalled.
Solex 35PDSIT (Scat kit)
Removable venturi - allows different sizes
Asymmetric throttle action (both throttles turn the same way)
Electric choke, fast idle capability in the choke housing, though out
of the box they are not set up this way. There are two positions on the
linkage. This can give fast idle on choke action
Separate throttle body under the main carburetor body
Throttle shaft rides on bearing inserts in the throttle body
Equipped with vacuum ports suitable for SVDA carburetor
Fuel pressure 3-3.5 PSI
Typical jetting at sea level: 55 idle, 135 main, 100 air + 90 fixed
air
Float hinges on pin in lower body section
Float settings - I don't have technical information on how these
are supposed to be set. These have the float attached to the cover,
which tends to be a matter of setting the float angle. Out of the
box, these do seem to be ok, though, I believe that they have one
0.5mm washer under the needle and seat.
Common problems:
Problematic throttle bodies out of the box.. many times I have
seen problems with these. The problems are plate shape errata, plate
alignment errors, mixture screw stuck, and sticking shafts. The
solutions to these problems can range from difficult
procedures to replacement throttle bodies. The last time I have
tried to get throttle bodies replaced, they've been out of stock,
and have never agreed to replace them for free, which is very
frustrating.
Older kits had problems with the cover gasket interfering with
the float, causing flooding or float sticking closed. This isn't a
problem in newer kits.
Difficult fitment on engines with OEM doghouse shrouds due to
throttle arm interference on right carb to the fresh air outlet, and
due to castings having bosses that foul the shroud on the left side.
See my article on
installing these for more details on this. The article is on this
site, also in the tech articles section. There is a lot of detail
there. These are probably the most difficult dual carb set to
install in some cases, but if you are aware of the obstacles, tackle
them and get these installed, they're pretty good carburetors.
Solex H40/44 EIS (Kadrons)
Removable venturi - allows different sizes. These carburetors can
provide more air flow than the other models listed here due to larger
throttle bodies, and can be used in larger engine setups.
Asymmetric throttle action (both throttles turn the same way)
These come in electric choke equipped and non-equipped versions.
Separate throttle body under the main carburetor body. 40mm or 44mm
throttle bodies can be used on these.
Throttle shaft rides on bearing inserts in the throttle body
These are not equipped with vacuum ports, though they can be modified
for them easily
Fuel pressure 3-3.5 PSI. I see arguments for 1.5 psi, and I don't
think that's true. I've never had trouble with 3.5 psi or even a little
more. The needle and seat on these is the same one used on other Solex
models. Now some of these do come with brass floats instead of plastic ones, and I think
that this is dealt with through washer changes under the needle to
adjust for the difference in buoyancy.
Typical jetting at sea level: 55 idle, 135 main, 100 air + 90 fixed
air
Float hinges on pin in lower body section
Float settings - about 17-19mm works well for me. Typically with
Solex carbs that have the float hinging on a pin in the lower body
section, you can arrive at a good float setting by doing what it
takes to make the float sit level in the float bowl
Common problems:
Problematic throttle bodies out of the box.. many times I have seen
problems with these. The problems are sloppy throttle shaft bores, and
too much throttle shaft end play.
On these units, the accelerator pump discharge nozzle is long, and
has a tendency to have its discharge zone too close to the venturi
height. Bending the tubing to raise it up but still shoot straight down
helps keep the tube from siphoning fuel at higher air speeds through the throttle body. If you
bend it enough to raise it above the venturi, this will eliminate the
problem.
Many times I see these units missing the tiny check ball under the
accelerator pump discharge tube, like the stock Solex units have. Using
one of these helps keep the entire accelerator pump circuit full, and
ensures a positive strong stream of fuel from the accelerator pump.
Mixture screw damage - sometimes overzealous adjustment causes the
screw to seat into the body too far, or someone changes the spring out
for a heavier unit. This causes the screw to bind the spring before the
mixture screw totally closes off in the seat. This causes the unit to be unable to be set
effectively. Getting the mixture to be able to go lean is part of being
able to set the mixture correctly. Using a lighter spring usually helps
with this unless the throttle body is really damaged. In this case the throttle body needs to
be replaced.
The linkage that these are typically equipped with is junk. I tend to
recommend the Scat universal linkage for these. Modification of the
throttle arms is necessary with this linkage, to make it work right.
Problems that exist with the standard linkage are :
a. Solid center link style rod does not allow for precise adjustment of
linkage for good synchronization. b. Snap joint ends tend to get
loose and pop off
How to modify throttle arms to be used with the Scat universal linkage:
Remove the throttle arms from the carburetors
Place them in a vice with the linkage ball facing down and between
the jaws
Carefully grind the formed rivet end flat and flush with the arm
Use a punch point to make a divot centered in the rivet body, so you
can drill through it.
Drill Through the rivet material with a drill slightly larger, until
you can see that the drill has cut as far as the rivet margin, into the
back of the throttle arm. Stop here, and use a punch and a hammer to
drive the ball out.
The bolts that come with the Scat linkage are a little larger than
the hole in the throttle arm, and you will need to use a drill bit large
enough to open the hole so the bolt can pass through it.
Dellorto FRD34B (Baby Dells)
Removable venturi - allows different sizes
Asymmetric throttle action (both throttles turn the same way)
These in mechanical choke equipped and non-equipped versions.
Throttle body is integrated to lower body section
Throttle shaft rides on casting bore
Equipped with vacuum ports suitable for SVDA carburetor
Fuel pressure 3-3.5 PSI
Typical jetting at sea level: 55-60 idle, 135 main, 160 air
Float attached to cover, easy to measure and adjust the float height
Float settings - closed position, measure 5-6mm from the edge of the
float furthest from the pivot to the gasket under the cover. The spring
loaded pin on the needle must not be compressed. The drop should measure
about 12-13mm
Parts diagram (click on it for bigger
size)
Float settings diagram
Common problems:
Throttle shaft bores wear causing air leaks around the throttle
shafts - these need to be bushed to be repaired. Unlike all the others
with 8mm throttle shafts, these have a 7.8mm throttle shaft, which
requires unique tooling to rebush them. Many times only the throttle arm side is worn enough to
need bushings.
Common topics for all dual 1bbl
carburetors
Throttle shaft wear and end play problems
With the pushing or pulling force of the
throttle cable or linkage, the throttle shaft is pushed against the shaft
bore and constantly digs into it. Over time, the hole ovals, often more
on the throttle arm side than the accelerator pump side. The slop
introduces air leaks, and causes difficulty with the linkage, namely
keeping it synchronized. Air leaks cause what is called "false air
" into the intake runner, which means air that is not controlled by
the existing system. Anything leaking from the throttle shaft is not metered
by the throttle plate system, and is not controlled. The false air does
not come with the effect of delivering fuel with it, and therefore dilutes
the air fuel mixture in a way that cannot be controlled, and which cannot be
compensated for in a dependable way.
Fuel leaking from the throttle
shaft is usually an indication of fuel pooling on top of the throttle plate.
This is usually only apparent after the engine has been shut off, because
vacuum at the throttle plate causes air to suck in rather than fuel to leak
out during the time the engine is running. This may be an indication that you
have excessive fuel pressure, or in inlet valve that is not closing off
completely. It may also mean float height issues. If this is the case, you may
still see fuel leaking out through the bushing after it is repaired. It may be
less, but if the problem is significant, you may still see some. I don't
consider fuel leaking from the throttle shaft area a sign of a loose throttle
shaft, though looser shafts will leak more. The leak is not caused by the shaft
wear itself.
The way to deal with worn throttle shafts is to restore the shaft hole,
which is a process in which the hole is opened up and an sleeve or
bushing is installed in the hole and the ID of the bushing is sized to
accommodate the size of the throttle shaft with close tolerance.
Materials range from replacement bushings made of plastic, soft metallic
materials like Garlock, or harder metallic materials like bronze. There
are certain materials that work better than others. Typically the
bushings are sized to a press fit into the body, and a size slightly
larger than the throttle shaft. Methods of preparing the body include
drilling or milling, using either a drill press or a mill. Then the
bushing is sized to fit the bore, and the ID of the bushing is reamed to
fit the shaft size. Shafts tend to wear a little, so this should be
closely matched using a series of reamers surrounding the shaft size.
The closer to the size of the shaft you can make the hole, the better.
As the hole size is increasingly larger than the shaft size, the rate of
air leak and the rate of wear increases. If you consider the radii of
the two matching items, a hole radius much larger than the shaft means
that only a tiny portion of the shaft touches the bore, and all force
contacts this point and causes more PSI on the wall of the hole, and
hence faster wear.
The other issue with throttle shafts is end play. When the throttle
shaft has uncontrolled end play, the throttle plate is allowed to slide
back and forth in the bore and then closure of the plate forces the
plate to become centered again by scraping against one wall of the
throttle bore. This repeated wear often causes the plate to wear on the
edge, and the throttle bore to wear into an oval shape as well. This
also destroys the precision of the throttle plate system, and increases
the air flow at any reasonably shallow throttle position. By controlling
this end play you can eliminate the cause of wear and greatly increase
linkage precision.
Linkage styles
There are a few different styles,
including crossbar, center pivot, and most recently added to the
arsenal, some cable driven linkage. Opinions range on the best linkage.
I tend to lean toward non-crossbar linkage because I feel that crossbar
linkage tends to wear quickly, and tends to have enough pivot points
that the collective weight, drag, and wear slop will make
synchronization more difficult. For asymmetric carburetors where the
throttles turn in the same direction, A push/pull style center pivot
style is best. For symmetric carburetors where each carburetor rotates
in the opposite direction, a push/push or a pull/pull linkage is best,
depending on linkage geometry.
Crossbar linkage:
Crossbar linkage has a horizontal
bar that pivots at the carburetors via pivots mounted to either
carburetor, the air filter, or sandwich plates under the air
cleaner. Close to the ends of the crossbar are arms mounted to the
crossbar that raise and lower as the crossbar is rotated. Near the
center of the crossbar is the actuating arm which has a cable
attached to it. When the cable is pulled, then the arm is moved,
rotating the crossbar. Connected to the arms at the ends of the
crossbar are down rods, which have joints at the top and bottom. The
down rods attach to the arms and then connect to the throttle arms on
the carburetors. This kind of linkage can be used easily with
symmetric and asymmetric carburetor setups. The version you
are looking at is Tayco. There are a few other brands, but the
idea is the same on all of them.
Push/Pull linkage:
This linkage has a center tower that pivots, with two arms
that protrude from the tower. One arm is connected to the throttle
cable, and the other is connected to either a single arm that spans
the two carburetors, such as in the case of standard Kadron linkage,
or two rods that attach to the arm, with the other ends connecting
to the carburetors. As the cable pulls one arm on the pivot, the
pivot is rotated, and the other arm moves the rods either left or
right, opening and closing the throttles on the carburetors.
The version you are looking at is Scat Universal linkage, which I
think is good for the price, and adapts well to Weber 34ICT, Solex
35PDSIT, Kadron (with linkage arm modifications), and Dellorto
FRD34B carburetor sets. You can see examples of it installed,
and the process I went through on my
35PDSIT page.
Push/Push or Pull/Pull linkage:
The principle is the
same as the push/pull linkage, and is a two rod design, whose pivot
attachments consist of two points on the pivots. These are arms 180
degrees from each other, so that when the pivot is rotated, the rods
move in opposite directions, either pushing or pulling the throttle
arms on the carburetors.
Fuel pressure
Fuel pressure on most every aftermarket carburetor setup for VW
aircooled engines tends to be agreeable around 3 to 3.5 PSI. Not all
pumps will deliver this pressure, and some require a regulator.
Regulators come in different kinds, with different mechanisms. To me buying a fuel pump and then having to
use a regulator is a waste of time and money when you can buy a pump
that delivers the pressure you need. The electric carter rotary pump
that is offered by Aircooled.net is the best pump I have found. It is rotary, quiet, and
delivers pressure until shut off, at which time residual pressure in the
line bleeds off. The advantage to an electric pump is that it tops off
the carburetors when you turn on the key, not requiring the engine to be cranked to do this.
This can result in quicker starts and less cranking time. The quality
OEM style mechanical pumps of yesterday are gone, and now the
replacements are a crap shoot, requiring testing and calibrating of pressure with gaskets stacked under
the pump body to reduce the spring tension applied to the delivery
stage. This would be ok, but often it requires reducing that pump
actuation so much that at higher demand conditions, the pump is unable to deliver the pressure and
volume it needs to. The alternative is to use a regulator with a
mechanical pump.
Regulators vary, and some are pure junk. The ones that do a decent job
tend to cost more. There are two types of regulators, namely deadhead
regulators and bypass regulators.
Deadhead regulators have an inlet for the fuel from the pump, and an
outlet or outlets that go to the carburetors, and work on a system of
springs inside that reference pressure by varying the spring tension. As
long as fuel is moving these work ok. But when there is no movement of fuel, they can allow the
pressure at the outlet to increase making them ineffective. Some do
better than others and are good enough to use.
Bypass regulators reference pressure dynamically all the time, and fuel
pressure above the desired pressure is relieved by bleeding off fuel to
a line that returns the fuel to either the tank or the inlet of the
pump. This type of regulator is superior in performance, and is commonly used in fuel
injection systems where a pressure of fuel in the injector ring is
critical.
For my money, you cannot beat the Carter rotary units. They are a
simple, reliable, quiet solution to the problem of fuel delivery.
One risk with electric pumps is that the pump could remain running in
conditions you would not want it to, such as vehicle accidents,
overturns, fires, etc., and for best measures, putting a safeguard
system in place is recommended. The system should be aware of accidents and overturns. This type of
system is beyond the scope of this write-up, but you can find examples of
these systems on the internet. I don't use this kind of system, but I am
a bad example! Recommending it is the responsible thing for me to do.
Float settings
This is one of the most critical parts of setting up your carburetors.
If you are unwilling to set your floats, you are unwilling to tune
correctly. Setting floats for the various carburetors is covered
individually below.
Balance tubes
Though I discuss balance tubes in the FAQ, I should mention them here
too, and say that sizes for these tubes varies from 1/4" to 1/2". The
larger the tube the faster the tube can compensate for pressure
differences. But the larger the tube, the larger the dynamic plenum space, and the more you have to
open the throttle plates at idle to attain the same idle speed. This is
an important point, namely because the more the throttle plates are
open, the more you expose the progression ports and the vacuum advance port at idle. You do
not want ANY vacuum from the vacuum advance port at idle or you will
engage the advance on the distributor at idle. One way of dealing with
this phenomenon is to drill air bleed pilots in the throttle plates, at a size suitable to
allow idle speed with the throttle plates as closed as possible. I'm not
going to get into a big discussion about that here, but I will say that
if you choose to do it, start small and conservative, because it is harder to close the
holes back down if you go too far. Start with 1mm holes and go up in
small increments until you get close to what you want with the throttle
speed screws engaged only a little bit instead of several turns. If they are engaged about a turn
after touch, that gives you some room to go either way, and you can fine
tune from there.
Carburetor sizing
There are charts for this that have been used over the years with good
success. I have my own calculator for it based on formulas, but the
charts follow that pretty well. I'd say stick with the charts. If you
are a masochist, you can use this formula to determine a venturi size based on your max RPM and
engine displacement.
Where:
Dv = venturi diameter Displacement= engine displacement Max RPM= expected RPM where engine will produce maximum power
The formula is a general guideline, not
fact, and variables are engine
combo, what you want to focus on, and practicality.
The Weber
ICT carburetors have a fixed venturi, cast into the body. This limits
the application to smaller engines than some of the others. I would not
put it on anything larger than a low revving 1835.
The
Solex/Brosol H32/34 PDSI -2 and -3 carburetors have a removable
venturi, and The largest venturi I know of for them is a 28mm venturi,
but if a pair were opened up to 30mm, you could probably feed a 1.9
liter engine with a power range up to about 5000 RPM.
The Solex 35PDSIT carburetors have a removable venturi, and I know that
Aircooled.net sells up to a 30mm venturi for them, which would probably
feed a 1.9 liter engine with a power range up to about 5000 RPM.
The Solex/Brosol H40/44 carburetors are more gray area.. depending
on what throttle body they have and how big a venturi you can cram in
them, you might be able to feed a 2 liter engine to about 5000 RPM. The
limiting factor is the venturi size you can put in them. The ratio for
venturi size to bore size should be somewhere between about 0.7 and
0.85. A 0.7 ratio means that the venturi is 70% the size of the throttle
body. So with that, it seems that with a 44mm throttle body, if you
could fit 36mm venturi in it, you could feed a 2 liter engine to about
6000 RPM, or a 2275 engine up to about 5500 RPM. But this sizing is
something I have never investigated. The body bore size will affect what
size vent you can use, and I have stuck with 40mm throttle bodies, and
up to a 32mm venturi, which would feed a 2 liter engine up to about 5500
RPM.
The Dellorto FRD34B carburetor can be outfitted with up to a 30mm
venturi. You could probably feed a 1.9 liter engine with a power range
up to about 5000 RPM with these.
Intake manifolds
Many times, intake manifolds on used
units, and even on new units, are not flat in the gasket areas. Dual
port intakes have potential at the carburetor flange and the cylinder
head flange as well. Single port intakes tend to have their problems at
the carburetor flange only. Checking these for surface flatness is an
important part of assembly. If you have access to a belt sander this is
a quick and easy way to deal with it. Remove studs from the carburetor
flange, surface it, and then reinstall the studs. You can tell if they
are approaching flat by looking at the wear area from the sanding. You
can also use a flat file if you are skilled with one. Over tightening the
carburetors or several installations and removals will cause this.
Sometimes the surfacing out of the box isn't good either.
Gasket types
I always recommend non-metal gaskets. They don't conduct heat as well,
but that's not as necessary with dual carb setups anyway. Metal gaskets
are a must with center mount carb setups if you want the best heat
conduction to the end castings, but with dual carbs, I never use them.
Mounting intakes to cylinder heads:
When you install intakes to cylinder heads, keep in mind that if the
intakes are aluminum, the only area that you get clamping force is the
end of the nut you use to install it. Many times people need to use
smaller nuts due to space considerations. With this, the clamping force is distributed over less
area. Using thick large area washers really helps with keeping them
tight. When the engine vibrates or shakes, the weight of the carbs pulls
on the bases, and the nuts will dig into the flanges, causing loose intakes. If you use
washers, you distribute the force from the hard attachment hardware to
more area on the soft flange material, and this doesn't happen anymore.
Ehen you install washers, often you cannot get them to fit due to the material at the base being
too close to the hole. Rather than clearancing the intakes, grind the
edge of the washer to make it more like a D shape, and it can clear
better and still offer plenty of support. Also make sure that the seating area where the washer
mates to the flange is flat and square so that the whole washer sits
flat, and the nut sits flat on the washer.
Location pins on heads:
Some older heads might still have these, and they can be a bitch to
remove. Two things that help:
Using a hammer and punch, apply some licks to it sideways to
loosen its fit to the hole in the head. Grab it with some pliers or
a pair of channel locks and pull it out.
Heat - it will expand the head a lot more than the steel pin.
Then it will come out easier.
FAQ
Why does my engine idle on #2 and #4 cylinder, and #1 and #3 seem
dead or weak?
This question comes up all the time, and some
people say it doesn't happen while some say it does. There are
factors that will affect how much this happens. Engine displacement,
cam profile, intake manifold design, carburetor model all affect the scale of the effect. If you have a setup like this, try
pulling the #1 and/or #3 plug wire loose from the cap, and observe that
the idle speed and quality doesn't change much. If you do this with #2
or #4, the engine will probably die.
So what's happening? Why does it do this?
BECAUSE.. that's all you need to know. That's why.
Ha! That's the answer that you will get from some people. Here's what I
think.
Look at one side. Let's pick the 1/2 side. You have an intake
manifold topped with a single barrel carburetor. The firing order
for these engines being 1-4-3-2 (or 2-1-4-3) means that on that
side, one cylinder's (#2) intake valve opens, pulls in the air/fuel
charge, and then the adjacent cylinder's (#1) intake valve opens
right after. The first cylinder (#2) has sucked in the air and fuel
that is in the manifold. Since the throttle plate is closed, or
nearly closed at idle, this leaves a partial vacuum condition in the
intake manifold. There is not enough time for the intake runner to
re-fill with air before the second cylinder's (#1) intake valve
opens. The second cylinder (#1) also leaves a vacuum in the intake.
Now, there are two cycles that occur on the other side while this
side sits with nothing happening with the intake valves. The vacuum
in the 1/2 intake has time to be relieved by the slow bleed of air
that makes it past the throttle plate, which is not completely
closed. With this air, fuel is also pulled from the idle circuit.
Now, by the time #2 intake is ready to open and pull the air/fuel
charge in, the vacuum has diminished and the air is dense and rich
with fuel. The #2 cylinder receives a strong charge of air and fuel
and leaves the intake manifold pressure low again (partial vacuum).
This means that when it is #1's turn right away to get its share,
there is not much for it to pull.
The same thing happens on the 3/4 side. So #2 and #4 are
getting dense rich air/fuel mixtures, and 1 and 3 are getting less
dense air/fuel mixtures. This happens as a result of the firing
order, the intake design, and the time frame that this has to occur.
The window of opportunity is right for this to happen.
So now you crack the throttle, and the engine speeds up. Not only
does it speed up, but it has much less tendency to maintain a vacuum
in the intake manifold because the throttle plate is open more. So
with the RPMs up and the plate open more, not only does the intake
suffer less vacuum effect, the time between one side's cycle and the
other side's cycle decreases, so that the vacuum is more uniform.
Jetting takes care of making sure fuel is delivered at the rate it
needs to be for this condition.
Ok, great, so what do you do about this odd firing situation? It's
making my engine run rough at idle.
Well, it shouldn't. If you think about the situation, the #2 and #4
cylinders are equal times apart. The "beat" is even, not like a
Harley Davidson, or like a single cylinder engine, or a miss. The engine can
idle smooth, and I have set up lots of these types of carburetor
setups. The key is that the carburetors are synched properly, and
that the mixtures are set correctly. With this, you can achieve a
smooth idle that is not shaky.
You say, "I can't deal with it.. I am some kinda neophyte that
MUST have 4 strong cylinders of idling fury!"
Tough love baby. I can help a little with it, but it will still do it a
little.
You can install a BALANCE TUBE!
What is a BALANCE TUBE?
Gee, I am glad you asked.
The 1972-1974 USA made Bay Window Bus was equipped with a dual 1bbl
carburetor setup, and so was a span of Type 3 vehicles. These were
factory equipped 32-34PDSIT and 32PDSIT carburetors, respectively.
VW wasn't going to put up with that odd firing silliness, no sir! So
they equipped the engines with a balance tube. This tube is just a
line connected between the two intake manifolds, which serves to
help equalize pressure and help fix the lean charge cycles by
allowing an exchange of air between the two sides.
The balance tube also serves another purpose, which is to keep the
intake manifold average pressures the same on both sides. This is
effectively what happens when you synchronize the carburetors to allow
the same rate of air bleed past the throttle plates.
In the case of an engine with the carbs out of synch, the balance
tube will equalize the pressure on the two sides by causing a net
flow of air from the higher flowing side to the lower flowing side.
If the carburetors are synchronized, there is an even exchange of
air back and forth with no net flow of air going from one side to
the other.
One effect of the balance tube is that in order to achieve the
same idle speed as an engine without the balance tube, you have to
open the throttle plates more. This can be observed by pinching the
balance tube on an engine that is so equipped, and observing that
the idle speed increases.
If you look at the bus carburetor setups, you will notice that the
balance tube runs from the base of each of the non-dominant
cylinders. This targets the low pressure zone a little better. Those
engines run pretty smooth, all things considered. I won't get into
what a pain in the butt those particular systems are to adjust and
tune here. Check out AMSKEPTIC's tech library for layout and tuning.
No need for me to re-invent the wheel.
This balance tube discussed in #3 is there to improve idle
quality and equalize pressure. Does this mean that I don't need to
pay attention to carb synch?
No!! And I will tell you why.
The balance tube has most effect at idle. As the vacuum in the
intakes decreases and the speed of the engine increases, it does
less to compensate. So at 1/3 throttle it's probably done, and if
you have the carbs out of synch, one WILL get more air and fuel than
the other. Synch is ALWAYS important.
Ok I'm convinced of #4, or I will just give you the glazed look
and accept it. Now I put my synchrometer on the two sides of my
balance tube equipped setup and they read the same.. in fact I can't
really make them read differently by adjusting the speed screws.
Does that mean they are balanced?
No. It means the balance tube is doing its job, but probably more
than you want it to. Pinch the tube off so air cannot pass between
the two sides. The idle speed will go up, yes, but ignore that for
now. Take readings this way, and you will probably see that they are
not the same. In this case, disconnect the linkage, adjust the speed
screws until they are, and the idle is a little higher than you
want. Now adjust the mixture screws for lean best idle. Then release
the balance tube. If you are happy with the idle speed, then you are
done with the carb synch. If you are not, then pinch it off again
and make a minor adjustment and release it again, until you are
satisfied. Now reconnect and synchronize the linkage.
How does the dual air jet setup work? What are the implications of
changing the removable one, versus carburetors with a single air jet?
Both of these air jets supply air to
the same circuit. In other words both contribute. The equivalent
size of the two air jets is the diameter associated with the sum of
their two cross sectional areas. In other words, you don't just add
the sizes of the two to get the equivalent size. You must calculate
their hole areas, add them, and then calculate what the diameter of
that hole would be. Think about it. If you had two one inch holes,
they would not make a 2 inch hole. Lay the two holes next to each
other, and then draw a circle that has the 2 inch diameter. Lots
more area in that circle than the two 1 inch circles contain.
So to calculate the equivalent size of two jets, you would set up the
formula like this:
Area A of a circle:
A=
or
There are constants here, and to do the conversion, you can drop
those, because you will simply multiply all the squared and summed
and rooted values by those and then in reverse, you will divide them
out.
Since we are dealing with diameter, let's use the second
formula. Drop the constants out, and use the diameters only. If you
want to prove it to yourself that the constants do not need to be
there, feel free. They cancel out. At any rate, here we go:
D1 = diameter of one air jet D2 = diameter of other air jet
Diameter of equivalent SINGLE jet =
So.. for air jets 140 and 90, you have:
Diameter of equivalent SINGLE jet =
or about 166
So the implications of changing the replaceable air jet on a dual air
jet carb are that the effective change in air jet size is less than
if you had changed the size of an air jet on a carb equipped with
one single equivalent air jet equivalent.
Prove it:
Change the air jet to 130 and 90.
Diameter of equivalent SINGLE jet =
or about 158
It is only 8 less, not 10 less,
like it would if you reduced the equivalent single air jet sized at
166 by a 10.
The effective change of the replaceable jet is related to the ratio
of the two. If the removable was considerably smaller than
the fixed, the effect would be less, per size. If the
removable was considerably larger than the fixed, the effective
change will be close to the change in that jet. Play around
with a few to see what I mean.
Should I use a distributor with vacuum advance?
If your camshaft is mild, you
should have a strong intake vacuum at low engine speeds and throttle
angles, and a vacuum advance distributor will be useful, especially
if you tune for mileage at cruise and use a lean mixture. Lean
mixtures have slower flame front propagation, and will benefit in
efficiency from the earlier spark event. Different distributors have
different requirements for vacuum strength, but stock SVDA
distributors and the aftermarket SVDA distributors tend to work as
long as you don't have a wild cam. Use of a wild cam tends to screw
you on cruise anyway, so the benefits of the distributor wouldn't be
enough to make it worth it anyway.
That's all I have for now. If you have any suggestions on things you
would like to add or see,
contact me!
***** TO DO: ***** Setup and tuning considerations